Employee, Worker or Self-employed? Comparing Status and Rights
The statutory definitions of the three categories of employment status have long been criticised as being unclear, and over the years a body of case law interpreting these definitions has grown up. Despite this, it remains difficult to set out a definitive list of criteria to allow employers or employees to determine whether an individual’s status is that of employee, worker or self-employed.
The Supreme Court in Aslam v Uber [2021] recently gave useful guidance on the approach that should be taken, particularly with vulnerable workers, emphasising that it is the actual arrangements on the ground that matter and not what the contract says.
To add to the confusion, the definitions of employee and worker vary depending on the various rights. The Uber judgment gives some clarity in determining worker status. The pivotal factor for the Supreme Court in finding that Uber drivers were workers, rather than self-employed, is the considerable control exercised by Uber when drivers had the Uber app switched on. In particular, Uber fixes the price and determines all aspects of the drivers’ interaction with passengers.
The issue of employment status has risen to the top of the agenda in many companies as new IR35 Rules regarding off-payroll working are in force from 6 April 2021.
In addition, differences in health and safety rights came under the spotlight following a recent case brought by a union representing gig economy workers in the context of the risks they face during the pandemic.
Currently only employees are protected against suffering a detriment, such as being demoted, because they left the workplace or took steps to protect themselves or others from a serious danger in the workplace. However, the High Court declared that workers should also be protected (The Independent Workers’ Union of Great Britain v The Secretary of State for Work and Pensions [2020]). In response, in March 2021, the UK Government put before Parliament draft legislation which will ensure that UK law reflects the full scope of protection in the EU directive, from which these rights originate. This will apply to any detriments a worker experiences on or after 31 May 2021.
To help employers and individuals to understand the key differences, the following table outlines the most significant rights and characteristics:
Comparing Key Differences between Employees, Workers and Self-employed
| Rights to | Employee | Worker | Self-employed |
|---|---|---|---|
| Protection from unfair dismissal and redundancy payment | Yes | No | No |
| Statutory sick pay and family-friendly rights | Yes | No | No |
| National Minimum Wage | Yes | Yes | No |
| Working Time Regulations, including right to paid holiday and limits on working hours | Yes | Yes | No |
| Equal pay, protection from discrimination and whistle blower protection | Yes | Yes | Generally, no but may in some circumstances |
| Statutory minimum notice period | Yes | No | No |
| Right to have a grievance heard | Yes | No | No |
| Implied duties, such as mutual trust and confidence and to not compete against employer | Yes | No | No |
| Relevant characteristics – employer control | Controlled by employer | Usually little autonomy or opportunity to profit through their own entrepreneurial skill | Independent, can determine how, when and where they do the work and may bear financial risk |
| Relevant characteristics – personal service | Yes – cannot send a substitute | Yes - usually personal service but may have a limited right to send a substitute | No obligation to provide services personally; can use substitutes |
| Relevant characteristics – integration into the employer’s business | Fully integrated | Some integration, for example if they have to wear a uniform and have an appraisal | Not integrated into business, for example not presented as part of the business and use their own equipment and email address |
| Relevant characteristics – employer must provide work and individual must accept offer of work | Yes | Yes | No |
| This chart is intended as an overview to highlight key differences only, and it does not address different statutory definitions of employee or worker. It does not cover specific classes of employee or worker to whom different rules apply. There are many other statutory employment rights, to which employees and workers are eligible, as well as health and safety rights. This chart does not constitute legal advice, and you should speak to an employment solicitor for advice on your particular situation. | |||
How we can help
Aside from potential liabilities to HMRC, getting an individual’s employment status wrong can give you a false sense of security. You may treat an individual as a worker and let them go without following a process or giving them notice. If they can convince an employment tribunal that they were actually an employee, you could face damages for unfair and wrongful dismissal.
Similarly, you may engage someone who describes themselves as self-employed and pay them less than the national minimum wage and not pay them for holidays. If it turns out they are actually a worker, you could be liable for significant back payments as well as being ‘named and shamed’ by the Government for failing to pay the national minimum wage.
One significant message from the Uber decision is that the contract has to match the reality of the working arrangements. An employment tribunal may disregard contractual provisions which try to classify the individual’s employment status.
We can help determine the status of any specific role in your business, and we can review your contracts and practices to advise on areas of risk. We can also help you to update policies and procedures to ensure that you comply with all the latest rules.
Please contact either Marie Colquhoun at mariecolquhoun@goodharts.co.uk or Anne Colquhoun at annecolquhoun@goodharts.co.uk or call us on 0191 687 2055.
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal or professional advice. Please note that the law may have changed since this article was published.